Men’s Fitness’ pick of the best whey protein powders for post-workout muscle recovery…

If you’re new to taking protein powder, the sheer number of brands and options can be overwhelming. So nutritionist Rob Hobson has done the hard work, so you don’t have to – testing eight of the best protein powders for texture, solubility, effectiveness and taste.

First, find out how to use protein powder

We’ve also taking into account availability, cost per serving and the variety of sizes and flavours available, as well as any recyclable packaging, which can all inform you buying decisions. 

For a portable protein fix get the best protein bars

These are the best protein powders

  1. Hermosa Whey Protein Powder ($72 / £67 for 1kg)
  2. Elite All Blacks Ultimate Whey Protein (£32.99 for 750g – not available in the US)
  3. Innermost The Strong Protein ($44.95 / £29.95 for 520g)
  4. Foodspring Whey Protein (£29.99 for 750g – not available in the US)
  5. Protein Works Whey Protein 80 (£24.99 for 500g – not available in the US)
  6. Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein ($44.99 for 2lb / £32.99 for 896g)
  7. Kinetica Whey Protein (£38.99 for 1kg – not available in the US)
  8. Myprotein Impact Whey Protein (£39.99 for 1kg – not available in the US)

Product shot of Hermosa whey protein powderBEST WHEY PROTEIN POWDER

Hermosa Whey Protein Powder

$72 / £67 for 1kg (33 servings) / livehermosa.com

Texture: 5/5
Solubility: 5/5
Effectiveness: 5/5
OVERALL: 5/5

Protein per serving: 21g | Cost per serving: £2.03 | Sizes: 10 x 30g / 420g / 1kg | Flavours: Chocolate / Vanilla

Hermosa is a right-on brand that makes protein products which are ethically sourced, sustainable and with non-GMO ingredients. While it’s pretty costly, its whey protein powder is the purest, smoothest and tastiest on test. No cloying sweetness or bitter aftertaste; just a delicious chocolate or vanilla shake that you’ll find yourself doing extra sessions just to get another serving of.

Read our full Hermosa Protein Powder review

These are the best clear protein powders

Product shot of Elite All Blacks protein powder blend
Elite All Blacks Ultimate Whey Protein Blend

BUY IT NOW:

£32.99 for 750g (20 servings) / healthspanelite.co.uk (not available in the US)

Texture: 5/5
Solubility: 5/5
Effectiveness: 5/5
OVERALL: 5/5

Protein per serving: 24g | Cost per serving: £1.65 | Sizes: 750g | Flavours: Chocolate / Strawberry / Vanilla

Elite All Blacks Ultimate is the protein powder of the all-conquering All Blacks rugby team. That’s a team that takes both performance and recovery seriously, so you can be confident this powder is the business. Flavours are rich but nicely balanced, it’s made with digestive enzymes and is Informed Sport-approved so suitable for elite competition.

Read our full Elite All Blacks Ultimate Whey Protein review

Product shot of a pouch of protein powder
Innermost The Strong Protein

BUY IT NOW:

$44.95 / £29.95 for 520g (13 servings) / liveinnermost.com

Texture: 4.5/5
Solubility: 4.5/5
Effectiveness: 4/5
OVERALL: 4.5/5

Protein per serving: 34g | Cost per serving: £2.30 | Sizes: 520g | Flavours: Chocolate / Vanilla

With a substantial 34g protein per serving, Innermost’s The Strong Protein will take care of your recovery needs. It’s a smooth and creamy shake too, and low in sugar, though the most expensive on test. So this may be one to save for your hardest sessions.

Read our full Innermost The Strong Protein review

Product shot of a tub of Foodspring whey protein
Foodspring Whey Protein

BUY IT NOW:

£29.99 for 750g (25 servings) / foodspring.co.uk (not available in the US)

Texture: 4.5/5
Solubility: 4.5/5
Effectiveness: 4.5/5
OVERALL: 4.5/5

Protein per serving: 24g | Cost per serving: £1.20 | Sizes: 750g | Flavours: Chocolate / Vanilla / Strawberry / Cookies and Cream / Coconut Crisp

Foodspring’s protein powder is another great-tasting shake, which is low in sugar, fat and calories. It’s good value, too, with 25 servings per 750g bag, each delivering 24g protein. It’s available in five flavours but only one sized tub, but that’s fully recyclable for those look to lessen their environmental footprint.

Read our full Foodspring Whey Protein review

Product shot of Protein Works sachets and two shakes with straws
Protein Works Whey Protein 80 Concentrate

BUY IT NOW:

£24.99 for 500g (20 servings) / theproteinworks.com (not available in the US)

Texture: 4.5/5
Solubility: 5/5
Effectiveness: 4.5/5
OVERALL: 4.5/5

Protein per serving: 20g | Cost per serving: £1.25 | Sizes: 500g / 1kg / 2kg / 4kg | Flavours: 14 flavours available

Protein Works’ shake has the fewest calories of any powder on test. It delivers 20g protein per 25g serving and is silky smooth once mixed. With four different sizes and 14 flavours to choose from, you’re bound to find an option to suit you.

Read our full Protein Works Whey Protein Concentrate review

Product shot of Optimum Nutrition whey protein tub
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein

BUY IT NOW:

$44.99 for 2lb (29 servings) / £32.99 for 896g (28 servings) / optimumnutrition.com

Texture: 4/5
Solubility: 4/5
Effectiveness: 4/5
OVERALL: 4/5

Protein per serving: 24g | Cost per serving: £1.18 | Sizes: 300g / 310g / 450g / 465g / 896g / 908g / 2.27kg / 4.54kg | Flavours: 12 flavours plus unflavoured versions available

Optimum Nutrition’s Gold Standard shake is widely available in health food stores and in sizes from 300g to 4.54kg. You’ve got 12 delicious flavours plus an unflavoured variety to choose from and both pouch and tub versions are 100% recyclable.

Read our full Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein review

Product shot of Kinetica whey protein
Kinetica Whey Protein

BUY IT NOW:

£38.99 for 1kg (33 servings) / uk.kineticasport.com (not available in the US)

Texture: 4/5
Solubility: 4.5/5
Effectiveness: 4.5/5
OVERALL: 4/5

Protein per serving: 22g | Cost per serving: £1.18 | Sizes: 300g / 1kg / 2.27kg / 4kg | Flavours: Vanilla / Chocolate / Chocolate Mint / Banana / Strawberry

Another good choice for elite athletes, Kinetica’s whey protein is Informed Sport-approved. It’s 1kg tubs are good value but you can bulk buy in 2.27kg or 4kg tubs for extra savings. It’s five flavours are gluten-free and suitable for vegetarians too.

Read our full Kinetica Whey Protein review

Product shot of a bag of Myprotein Impact whey powder
Myprotein Impact Whey Powder

BUY IT NOW:

£39.99 for 1kg (40 servings) / myprotein.com

Texture: 4/5
Solubility: 3.5/5
Effectiveness: 4.5/5
OVERALL: 4/5

Protein per serving: 21g | Cost per serving: £0.99 | Sizes: 250g / 500g / 1kg / 2.5kg / 5kg | Flavours: More than 40 flavours available

Myprotein’s Impact powder is the cheapest shake on test per serving. It’s low in calories, fats and sugars too and can be bought in a wide range of sizes. Myprotein’s USP here though is the sheer number of flavours available – with a dizzying array of more than 40 to choose from.

Read our full Myprotein Impact Whey Powder review

Rob Hobson is a registered nutritionist (AFN) and sports nutritionist (SENr), He works with private clients, including those looking to improve their health and body shape, and athletes looking to improve their performance. He also works with wellness brands, helping with product development, insight and marketing.